Mickey, Ryan, and Jack hunt down another of Uncle Lewis’s cursed antiques: a small cherub statue holding a quiver of arrows. The quiver gives its owner the power to make anyone fall obsessively, violently in love with them — but it’s not real love. The victim becomes a stalker, willing to kill anyone they see as a rival. The trail leads them to a lonely, socially awkward man named Lloyd, who’s using the arrows to force a beautiful coworker, Valerie, to “love” him. When she rejects other men, the curse compels her to attack them, leaving a string of assaults and one murder.
The trio realizes the quiver is corrupting both Lloyd and Valerie — he’s addicted to the control, and she’s trapped by the unnatural obsession. When Jack and Ryan try to intervene, Valerie turns on them under the arrow’s influence. Mickey manages to get through to Lloyd, making him see that what he has isn’t love, it’s possession. Desperate to free Valerie, Lloyd shoots himself with an arrow, turning the obsession inward until it destroys him. With Lloyd dead, the spell on Valerie breaks. They recover the quiver and lock it in the Vault. The episode closes with the group shaken, noting how the antiques twist basic human needs like love and connection into something monstrous.
